View Single Post
Old February 24th, 2008, 11:14   #118
Dog Face Killer
Dog Face Killer's Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Toronto
Originally Posted by LyquidFyre View Post
I'm not a legal expert by far but in those cases posted by DFK. I see the decision was "The appeal is dismissed" and doesn't that mean that it was essentially thrown out and the initial decision FOR the CBSA was upheld?

These three:

Therefore...Fail, by the appellant.
Your absolutely correct!
That is not the issue here...the issue is why it was dismissed...reason is that the guns in question met all three criteria to be considered a "replica". If the guns had only met 2 of the three criteria, then the person appealing the CBSA would have won the appeal!
Oh wait, was she a great big fat person?
Dog Face Killer is offline   Reply With Quote